
I've decided to give up the futile battle with Sony’s God forsaken software and have gone Apple. My old 2GB
NW-A608 Sony Network Walkman doesn't play Mp3 files sadly enough, since Sony had a fit of insanity and outlawed Mp3 files for the sole purpose of destroying Sony's once so bright future.
This means that all files must be converted from Mp3 to a format the player can actually play, which makes Sony's software obligatory for the transfer and subsequent conversion of any Mp3 files.
To make thing worse, Sony's software is a constant headache and will run any modern computer to the ground (just google ”Sony Connect Software” or read the C-Net article ”
How Sony failed to Connect, again”). There are ways of circumventing the main issue, the Sony Connect software and it’s evil minions, and use a program called MP3FileManager. The program presents a simple window with the songs on the player and allows you to convert and transfer songs with a simple drag and drop interface.
That solves all problems but one, conversion still takes time. It also introduces a new problem, the software isn't compatible with the NW-A608 in any conventional sense of the word. You’ll have to format your player, remove any Sony Connect software from your computer and hope for the best. [Here's a link to Deviators Blog - "How to use MP3 File Manager on NWA-608".]
The design of the NW-A608 player on the other hand is actually quite ingenious. There's a small knob around the mini-jack connection which when in its lowest position locks the keys, lift it to unlock then rotate left/right to skip song (hold to fast forward), pull it out to the next position to change and rotate left/right to change group (hold to fast skip). Sony calls this the ”jog dial” and I've got to hand it to them, it is very handy. The sound quality of the NW-A608 is good, but not great and the equalizer function is limited to adjusting ”Bass” and ”Treble” between +3 and -4. The display is an OLED built into the body of the player and virtually useless in sunlight.
When most people hear "Mp3 player" and ”Apple” nowadays they think "Nano". The Nano is a rather impressive machine, but I can't help to escape the notion that the player wants to be a small entertainment station with it's games, radio, color screen and what not. Needles to say, one machine can't do it all - not well anyways.
The color screen of the Nano emits an annoying high pitch background noise and the player can't quite power anything larger then a normal sized earbud - even when the volume limiter is off.
Comparing my new Shuffle to the NW-A608 I’m sacrificing 1GB of storage space, the screen, equalizer functions and the jog dial. What do I gain? Very good sound, complete integration with my PC’s iTunes, very fast file transfers and no more Sony.
One might argue that the equalizer function will be sorely missed, but on the bright side the Shuffle plays the music in its "native form" and as far as sound quality goes, there's actually no need for an equalizer with the Shuffle. Other iPods has taken some flak due to the fact that their equalizer function will drain the battery faster, and even more so due to their, under certain conditions, questionable audio quality. The sound of the iPod Shuffle is not as bass heavy as most Mp3 players with equalizer activated, so if you’re looking for a pounding bass line you might want to look elsewhere. However the sound quality is crystal clear and piano just sounds divine on my Sennheiser HD 215. The more I listen to it, the more I love it.
Yes, the sound may be a bit "too bright" but after listening a while you really get the sensation of the audio quality. Google around a bit and you'll find that most reviewers rate the Shuffles sound as top notch.
There are two metal sliders on the Shuffle, one used for power on or off (and check battery) and one for shuffle or playlist. To restart the playlist you press "play" three times and to lock the keys you hold play for three seconds.
The Shuffle use the standard iPod controls (volume up/down, next/previous song - hold for FF/FR, middle button for play/pause - hold to lock keys) but without the "touchscreen" dial of it's larger sized relatives.
The Shuffle has two diodes, one on either side, which informs the user of the players state (keys locked, charging - do not disconnect, max volume, error, no music available, paused and so on). Each diode can present a orange, red or green color. For instance, if you want to check the battery level while playing, just move the power slider to off and quickly back to on. The diodes will now flash green for high, orange for low and red for very low.
The software/synchronization/song transfer is just a breeze, as with most iPods. I've been using iTunes for a few years now and having it synchronize with the player while it is charging without the need for any extra software is just lovely. I often edit MP3 files if the song has a long silence or when the occasional numbskull left the intro of the next song at the end of the file. As you change the MP3 file on your hard drive the iPod will synchronize it's songs with the new version of the file at the next synchronization, very handy.
A review at
SweClockers (in Swedish) clocked the transfer rate of the Shuffle to 3,4 megabytes per second. They also noticed some background hiss, but only with certain headphones.
Due to the high sound quality of the Shuffle it is, as usual, wise to stay clear of crappy made VBR files, all 128 kbit/s files and to some extent 160 kbit/s files, the sound quality just isn't high enough.
I love the idea of the Shuffle, strip everything that’s not vital to the one and only task of any Mp3 player; to produce high quality sound. Color screens, radio, voice recording functions are all built into the same circuit board which makes the battery drain faster and is likely to adds hiss in the background of your music. Not to mention the price the manufacturers dare to ask for a product with all these functions you’ll rarely use.
The Shuffle uses the 3,5mm mini-jack connection to charge the player and transfer songs.
Just plug in the USB and place the Shuffle in it's docking station. When firmware updates are available, iTunes opens a dialog window from which you can choose to either install or ignore updates. Very handy.
Here’s a more in depth review of the Shuffle by Jacqui Cheng at Arstechnica which culminates in the eventual destruction of the device. It may be dead, but it took one hell of a pounding before it checked out.
So, to the bottom line. Is the iPod Shuffle the Mp3 player for you? Well, most prospective Mp3 player buyers craves functions, appearance and new features in their new player.
The Shuffle doesn't look all that impressive, it doesn't really have any extra features (no radio, no screen, no games). Unless you've had a chance to listen to it's sound or read a few in depth reviews, most shoppers are unlikely to choose the Shuffle unless they really need a compact device. Personally it's a no-brainer - an Mp3 player should play music, any other function usually comes with a price. Color screens? How many minutes do you look at your Mp3 players screen in comparison to how many hours of music you listen to? Radio? If you like radio then buy a radio, an Mp3 player should play Mp3 files. Games? Buy a portable game playing device - the games are better and the controls more suited for game play.
Apart from a good Mp3 player you'll need a good pair of headphones. My Sennheiser HD 215 headphones isn't exactly Sennheisers most exclusive model but they really get the job done. The sound of these headphones are balanced without either a too loud bass or piercing treble. I've listened to these headphones several hours straight without any ”ear fatigue” and the sound quality quite ok. Update - I've upgraded to AKG K420 Studio headphones, a huge improvement which definitely puts the HD 215:s to shame.
In summation, the iPod Shuffle isn't for everyone but if you are more interested in high quality audio then color screen and games this just might be your kind of player. Uncompromising and straightforward, the Shuffle is an MP3 player - nothing else.
Labels: audio, Review